That’s a really cool site you have, brings back memories!
I almost gave up on identifying this one, but maybe you can name that trauma:
I’m looking for a movie I saw about 13 years ago, when I spent a lot of time watching horror films in a friend’s basement.
It’s probably pretty old. I’m quite sure that it was black and white, but maybe it’s just very dark.
The story takes place in a house in a forest (or by a forest). I have a blurry memory of a man arriving at the house and being welcomed by a family, but maybe I’m mixing things up here with another movie.
There was a grown up daughter who was treated like a little girl and I think they had at least two children.
In the end the girl is holding her dead baby in a rocking chair (or a cradle?). I’m not even sure there was a real baby. It might be that she just believed she had a baby and that she was swinging something else.
I know that’s not much to go with, but that last scene was really memorable, so maybe someone can recall the name?
UPDATE: NAME THAT TRAUMA SOLVED! Special thanks to SlasherChick for answering it with AMERICAN GOTHIC.