
It’s hard not to appreciate Writer/director Mike Flanagan’s devout commitment to the horror genre. He appears game to tackle anything, has a zillion counterintuitive concepts up his sleeve and is even known to occasionally spin semi-gold from stinky straw (looking at you OUIJA: ORGIN OF EVIL). He’s wowed me on many occasions but he also has a tendency to gild the lily and mangle classic tales to the point that they lose part of their identity. I wasn’t crazy about the liberties he took with the great Shirley Jackson’s THE HAUNTING OF HILL HOUSE but I had to admit he delivered a fascinating ghost story of his own (at least until its regrettable tacked on happy ending). His attention to detail adapting Stephen King’s DOCTOR SLEEP is remarkable yet his cringy finale, which involves the Overlook hotel’s tortured spirits teaming up to exact vengeance, makes me want to throw a chair through a window (plus, what kinda nut benches the creepy bear/dog phantom?). I guess I’ll always be interested in what he’s cooking (looking forward to rolling the dice on EXORCIST: MARTYRS & would even give CARRIE season 2 a stab) but I gotta admit something about his taste and/or decision making skills historically doesn’t always click with me (and its not because I’m a traditionalist who can’t accept fresh takes, I nearly cheer with pom moms for Rob Zombie’s HALLOWEEN interpretations and I’m the lone person in North America who blesses 2011’s THE THING prequel). Also please notice I have nothing derogatory to say about MIDNIGHT MASS, that one is stellar and is kind enough not to step on any established classics toes.

The tale of Stephen King’s CARRIE has been recounted several times before (& even more if we’re counting RAGE 2 and the musical) so it makes sense that to justify a new rendition something new should be brought to the table. How about being the first to present Carrie as a book accurate unattractive annoying schlub? Nah, let’s add a secret cabal of meta-humans that infiltrate the prom in an attempt to recruit! Honestly, I wish I could say my biggest complaint in regards to Flanagan’s eight episode miniseries/possible pilot was its additions, the truth is that it’s what is left out and discarded that really stings. This Jenga tower tumbles not because of the pieces sloppily added to the top but because of the important emotional structural pieces hastily ripped out of the spine. Carrie’s all important relationship with her mother is severely muted and uncomfortably simpatico at times. At 394 minutes nary a moment is given to explore her complicated relationship with sometimes ally gym teacher Miss Desjardin (Collins per De Palma). Instead, we get framing history lesson vignettes before each episode and meandering moments with faculty members at a local watering hole.

In some ways every generation gets the “Carrie” they deserve. Theoretically, it’s absolutely understandable to update the story so that it’s relevant to modern teens in the hopes that they might relate. The problem is, the current state of our culture leaves a lot to be desired and a lot of our so-called advancements are lifeless, aesthetically bland and objectively un-cinematic. I want to watch a movie, I don’t want to be forced to routinely look at someone’s social media account, watch random texts roll by, observe a Tik Tok dance or witness characters filming influencer videos with a ring lamp; at least not when I could be watching bullies being burned alive at the prom. Flanigan's version of the fateful cathartic event that both Carrie and the viewer have richly earned lasts about five minutes and is contaminated by unintroduced characters rambling about, a possession of sorts that absolves Carrie from all blame and agency and a general rage-free emotional disassociation that flattens the entire affair. All that could be forgiven if it was recouped by Carrie’s final confrontation with her mother but that too feels limp and lacking of fervor. Maybe it’s me, I guess I just prefer my Carrie leaning more towards a demented Tennessee Williams play than an X-man comic book. Is part of getting older liking each new version of CARRIE less and less? From what I’ve seen Flanagan hit the nail on the head with the young crowd he was aiming for so maybe I’ll just keep De Palma’s work of art (complete with God teir Donoggio score) in my heart and shuffle off.

Maybe I’m just an old dog who can’t learn these new tricks (or Haute & Freddy songs). The truth is, Flanagan’s talent is such that even if he burns the main course, you can be sure there’s plenty of worthwhile side dishes and appetizers. Samantha Sloan is phenomenal as Margaret White. There’s a scene in which she takes the spreading of information at the high school into her own hands that is one for the ages. I would have loved for the script to allow her to go full beast mode. Summer H. Howell is perhaps too genuinely likable to pull off being a true outcast but she’s compelling just the same and subtly weird enough to ultimately convince. Where several individuals come off emotionally diluted compared to previous incarnations. Alison Thorton’s Chris Hargenson expands from being a one note bully into a more well rounded, complicated soul who is arguably experiencing an even more toxic home life than Carrie. It’s a shame more characters were not fleshed out in the same way. Josie Totah’s Tina Blake steals/saves every scene she’s in and I’m not sure how I would have gotten through the miniseries without her. Finally it’s hard for me to be too mad at a show that also operates as a spot the BATTLESTAR GALACTICA alumni game. There’s literally half a dozen actors from that much missed series popping up throughout CARRIE and I wholeheartedly got a kick out of that. So say we all.

But wait! Here comes a fresh new reason why you should probably take my opinion with a giant grain of salt! It turns out I rather enjoyed Rob Savage’s trippy and camp-tastic OTHER MOMMY, a movie reviled by critics and audiences alike! I swear I’m not trying to be contrary or special. I honestly can see why OTHER MOMMY isn’t dodging laurels due to it being a swirling structure-free avalanche of insanity but I found its surreal, go for broke, logic-be-damned fully inebriated, giddy nature refreshing. There’s zero bracing or coddling as Savage immediately throws the viewer into the coldest and deepest part of the pool and forces them to keep up with the bonkers waking nightmare that is well underway. Even the characters involved are not gifted with so much as a moment to process or rationalize events, they just gulp and accept their ridiculous new normal of perpetual unhinged day-glo lunacy. The steady anything can happen at anytime stance even brought me back to the groovy good ol’ days when watching A NIGHTMARE ON ELM STREET could shake your mental bearings and leave you with a tentative grasp on reality.

Little seven year old Bella (outstandingly played by Arabella Olivia Clark) has befriended a trickster entity who she calls "other mommy" that dwells in her closet and looks exactly like her workaholic mother Ursula (Jessica Chastain). Everyone needs friends but maybe not the kind that bends time at will, randomly transports you to bizarre dimensions, masquerades as those closet to you, and constantly pressures you to vacate your body so they can inhabit it in your place. Bella’s parents (including Jay Duplass as “Daddo”) naturally think Bella’s pal is imaginary until the shenanigans go way past explainable, the house nearly burns down and the specter begins appearing under cabinets with its limbs twisted up in impossible distortions. Wisely the clan fleas the property faster than the Lutzs’ skipped out of Amittyville but the wicked force isn't taking no for an answer and is constantly on their heals projecting hallucination whammies. Luckily for them Ursula’s mother knows a thing or two about the supernatural so they head to her seaside mansion and lucky for me said ghostbuster granny Ruth is played by the coolest and most beautiful lady who ever lived, Karen Allen (she of GHOST IN THE MACHINE ('93) fame, of course).

Sorta sloppy, undisciplined and downright maddeningly nonsensical OTHER MOMMY may be, but it also does an incredible job relaying the frightening feelings of childhood when it’s hard to decipher what’s real or trustworthy in the world and adults/parents can become horrifying strangers and/or threatening at the drop of a dime (An attempt is made to shove a “truth will set you free” parable in at the end but I think the stronger message involves standing your ground and simply punching fear in the face until it gets bored and splits). There’s also a lot of great ALICE IN WONDERLAND meets CORALINE vibes going about and more than a few innovate visuals and creature designs. OTHER MOTHER clearly is not going to be everyone's cup of glitter glue but the colorful creativity it expresses harkens back to the effervescent ‘80s/‘90s and that’s a treat on its own. I feel like it will gain traction and grow in appreciation in the years to come but don’t carve that in stone because I’ve been wrong before! In any case, yours truly is not going to harangue a movie that proudly bookends itself with Haircut 100’s “Favourite Shirts (Boy Meets Girl)”. That's for sure.











































































