
Hello, wonderful people of Kindertrauma!
I’m Matt Forgit, the author of It’s Always Halloween Here, How To Be a Professional Mourner, The Felicitous, and You Better Watch Out. My most recent book is a work of non-fiction entitled My Favorite Final Girl, where I collected essays from sixty amazing and talented horror authors, creators, and enthusiasts. Each essay is dedicated to a different final girl, celebrating their cultural and personal impact. You’re not here for my resume, though, so let’s talk final girls.
My guess is, if you’re here reading Kindertrauma, you know all about final girls and their importance and legacy in horror. The final girl is a tried-and-true force of nature, the audience surrogate, and the hero we need to conquer villains and nightmares. We all know the strong, smart, capable, brave, resilient, and resourceful ladies who have earned their spot in The Final Girls Hall of Fame™—Sally Hardesty, Jess Bradford, Laurie Strode, Ellen Ripley, Alice Hardy, Ginny Field, Chris Higgins, Nancy Thompson, Kirsty Cotton, Alice Johnson, Rachel Carruthers, Sidney Prescott, Erin Harson, Sienna Shaw, and so many more. But for every Sidney that we champion and root for, there are another dozen courageous and intelligent final girls who don’t always get their flowers.
So, here are five underrated final girls who I think don’t get the credit and shout-outs they deserve. Also, why isn’t there a Final Girls Hall of Fame™ Museum? We need to get on that.

Trish Jarvis (Kimberly Beck)—Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter (1984)
Look, I get it. Tommy Jarvis delivered the “killing” blow to Jason Voorhees. But what about Trish, who spent the previous twenty minutes being chased, jumping out of windows, smashing boxy TV sets over the hockey-masked murderer’s head, and growling “I’m going to give you something to remember us by!” as she swings a machete at the hulking Jason? Trish gets none of the recognition. It’s always (best Jan Brady voice here) “Tommy, Tommy, Tommy!” Trish is a fierce protector to her younger brother, fighting off Jason with the clawed end of a hammer and making sure they don’t meet the same gruesome fate as the teens across the road. She spends the finale of the movie running, screaming, distracting Jason, and defending Tommy’s safety, all for Tommy to swoop in at the end and get all the glory. Trish proves herself to be a formidable opponent to a very angry Jason (this was pre-zombie Jason, so he is running at a full sprint after her). Tommy wouldn’t have been able to finish Jason off if Trish hadn’t gone into combat mode to save them. Justice for Trish!

Meg Penny (Shawnee Smith)—The Blob (1988)
Meg is first depicted as the All-American girl-next-door construct that writers love to use; a pretty, easygoing cheerleader who symbolizes the idealized wholesomeness of Americana. Little do we know, at first, that Meg is a powerful force to be reckoned with. After the worst first date in history, Meg becomes the driving force in rescuing her town. Since no one believes her when she tells of the pink, gelatinous man-eater that devoured the football hero, Meg takes it upon herself to save the townspeople. She’s the movie’s true hero. She is aware of what is happening, proactively trying to prevent any further carnage, saving her brother, learning the true nature of The Blob’s origin, and calling out the local bad boy on his hypocrisy, which ultimately gets him to join her fight. By the last act, she is fending off the alien threat with a machine gun, then a snowmaking truck equipped with liquid nitrogen tanks. Meg never quits in her quest against the monster and proves herself to be the smartest and most take-charge person in the film.

Meagan (Nicole de Boer)—Prom Night IV: Deliver Us from Evil (1991)
Meagan is clearly a graduate of The Laurie Strode Final Girl Academy™. She’s soft-spoken, contemplative, and observant. However, when it comes down to it, she’s fully able to use her intelligence (and whatever is lying around) to defend herself. After the worst prom night ever, Meagan must battle with a possibly supernatural, non-aging monk with a looksmaxxed jawline named Father Jonas, who really, really hates prom night, young people, and Meagan’s blue baby doll dress. While all her friends fall victim to Jonas’ reign of terror, Meagan turns bug spray and shovels into weapons, making it clear to Jonas that although she is kind, she is also a fearsome fighter who won’t tolerate his depraved shenanigans. Boundaries! Laurie would be proud.

Maya Larkin (Winona Ryder)—Lost Souls (2000)
Maya isn’t a final girl in the traditional sense, yet she is the last one standing in a fight against the devil and his disciples, and the definition and parameters of “final girl” are ever evolving. Maya, who had been possessed as a teenager, has the unenviable task of convincing people that Satan will be reborn in the soul of writer Peter Kelson. As expected, nobody believes her. I mean, would you? We’d probably think she was the horror movie equivalent to Home Alone 2’s bird lady, except she collects doll heads and thinks the Big Mouth Billy Bass talks to her. But Maya is both sane and right, as well as persistent and dedicated, so that doesn’t stop her. She goes full Nancy Drew and conducts her own investigation and research while fighting off Satanists, hallucinations, and a previously comatose, now-escaped serial killer. By the end of the film, she’s shooting people left and right and is the only one who ensures the world is safe from Peter’s transformation. Bonus points because this is the great, luminous Winona Ryder!

Maggie (Laura Harris)—Severance (2006)
Picture it: you’re on a work retreat in the middle of the dense woodlands in a foreign country, with no escape route, transportation, or viable help within miles. Then a group of psychotic soldiers shows up, determined to annihilate outsiders. That’s the unfortunate situation Maggie finds herself in. However, the soldiers aren’t prepared for Maggie, whose motto (figuratively and literally) is “shoot first, ask questions later.” This is best demonstrated when, as she and her coworker Steve are surrounded by masked commandos, she instantly fires upon one to let them know she’s not bluffing. Maggie puts up a ferocious physical fight against the marauders; even when they have the upper hand, she summons her inner Tom Petty and won’t back down. Though Maggie is vulnerable, as we all would be in this situation, her sheer determination to survive is impressive and formidable.

Bonus for the Holidays!: Kelli Presley (Katie Cassidy)—Black Christmas (2006)
Poor Kelli just wants to have a nice Christmas. She can’t go home because she has to work, and her boyfriend is exposed as a cheating creep. Worst of all is Agnes, the freaky weirdo in her sorority house attic, whose reunion with her mental asylum-escapee brother Billy (think Cousin Eddie but extra deranged) means Kelli’s friends are being picked off one by one. Kelli is observant and aware; she knows something is wrong, figures out the family connection between Agnes and Billy, rallies her sorority sisters to fight, and never wavers. She fights back both mentally and physically against the jaundiced duo. “What have you done, Billy?” she rasps into her flip-phone, letting him know that she knows who he is and what he did last Christmas (or, rather, twenty or so Christmases ago). In the end, Kelli sees to it that Billy meets the pointy end of a hospital Christmas tree. In addition, Black Christmas gives us the iconic, lovable character Leigh Colvin (played by the outstanding Kristen Cloke), a smart and feisty almost-final-girl comrade to Kelli. No matter how many times I’ve seen this movie, I refuse to believe that Leigh does not make it to the end alongside the awesome Kelli. You deserved better, Leigh!
There you have it! Five (well, six) final girls who don’t seem to get the love and attention they’ve rightfully fought for. What would horror be without final girls? Thank you so much for reading, and thank you to my pals at KT for having me! Wishing everyone nothing but happiness, good health, success, and the fortitude of horror’s final girls. Please go check out the official My Favorite Final Girl page on Instagram!

Matt,
Thanks for the awesome post and for putting together the MY FAVORITE FINAL GIRL book!
What a great idea and a handy tome when looking for ideas on something to watch! Love the illustrations too!
Really glad you included Shawnee Smith’s Meg Penny from THE BLOB (’88) in your underrated list here! She’s one of my all time favorites and I always love when she grabs the gun and is shouting “Come on, You can do better than that!” At the titular space menace! She should always be mentioned when talking about the best of the best!
And thanks for mentioning BLACK CHRISTMAS too! That’s a yearly watch around here! Very much wish we could add Cloke’s amazing Leigh on the list as well! She’s my favorite and I’ve heard she was meant to have a better fate but it was changed last minute!
Also glad to know I’m not the lone LOST SOULS fan in the world! I need to watch that again soon!
ALSO: I’d like to invite any of our readers to come up with their own TOP FIVE FINAL GIRLS list! We’d be happy to share them! And please check the links in this post to purchase Matt’s awesome book (s)!