Look at the face above, doesnâ€™t that say it all? There are dozens of moments of virtuoso horror conduction in ROBERT WISEâ€™s masterpiece THE HAUNTING, yet the presentation of that visage is the one I anticipate with equal excitement and dread. WISE has directed classic films in nearly every genre, he edited CITIZEN KANE and uncredited scenes in THE MAGNIFICENT AMBERSONS, more importantly as far as what we are talking about here, he was the protÃ©gÃ© of dyed in the wool dark conjurer VAL LEWTON. Here we find the ultimate tribute to his mentor.
The cameraâ€™s concentrated stare at that (imagined/not imagined) face on the wall is a moment when we can catch WISE in the act of basically teaching the audience how to watch a horror film. Donâ€™t be surprised if for the rest of the movieâ€™s running time you are subconsciously on the look out for secondary images within the constant clashing of patterns and off angles within the nearly breathing beast known as Hill House. I have to laugh when people use words like â€œsubtleâ€ and â€œsuggestiveâ€ when describing THE HAUNTING. Make no mistake, this is an aggressive mind-fuck campaign youâ€™re witnessing. Just because youâ€™re too clueless to realize youâ€™re being mugged does not mean your wallet isnâ€™t already empty.
Watching THE HAUNTING once again, it was my intention to do a post pointing out the near onslaught of points of unease, the countless eyes on doorknobs and statues that glare at the occupants, the molten black tar shadows that cling to the walls, the endless maze of twisted corners and that damn spiraling, dizzying staircase, but boy did I get lost in the halls of Hill House myself yet again. It seems no matter how many times I visit this gothic funhouse I never exit the same door that I did the last time. I went in looking for that face on the wall and I exited transfixed by another.
THE HAUNTING hasnâ€™t the luxury of time on its hands to deliver the full all-encompassing apprehension of SHIRLEY JACKSONâ€™s novel THE HAUNTING OF HILL HOUSE, but a finer facsimile I doubt is humanly possible. Several of the filmâ€™s b-lines and amplifications can even be seen as improvements. CLAIRE BLOOM certainly brings an effervescence to the character of â€œTheoâ€ not found on the page and well, if any actor has ever â€œownedâ€ a part it is JULIE HARRIS as Eleanore â€œNellâ€ Lance (Vance in the novel). Oh yes, here is another example of your Unkâ€™s favorite type of horror character, heroism-free and verging on unsympathetic. Quit simply, Nellâ€™s a mess and easy pickinsâ€™ for Hill House.
When Dr. Markway (RICHARD JOHNSON) invites Nell to join his small team of investigators at the title mansion he does so due to his knowledge of her attracting paranormal activity in the past (which Nell denies.) He has no idea that she has recently lost her overbearing mother to whom she was caretaker. Nell jumps at the chance to start a new life and be free but the reality is she is hardly equipped for the outside world. Her life has been spent fulfilling the needs of others and suppressing herself. She talks a good game (mostly to herself via voice over) but when the world doesnâ€™t accept her with open arms, she recklessly attempts to flee back into the womb. Her real mother may no longer be available but the mother that is Hill House certainly is. (Notice that the most haunted room in the joint is the nursery.)
We are told many stories throughout the course of the film (and novel) some are relevant, some are conjecture and some are outright lies (Nell seems most happy when offering up falsities about her stone li(e)ons and fictional apartment.) One tale that overshadows all is the legend of the paternal evil in the house, Hugh Crain, but if you ask me he is a diversion from the source of Nellâ€™s real threat. The last occupant of Hill House was Hughâ€™s daughter Abigail and her death perfectly echoes Nellâ€™s motherâ€™s right down to an unanswered knocking on a wall for assistance with a cane. During one of the supernatural visitations we even witness Nell responding to a similar knock on the wall thinking it IS her mother.
When Nell find the words â€œEleanor come homeâ€ scrawled on a wall by a ghostly scribe we automatically imagine her recently departed mom pleading for her return but is it in actuality this other woman begging her to stay? As in â€œCome home to what you are used to Nell, you were born to be subservient to the likes of me, not a social being with a life of your own.â€
In the film (not so much in the novel) there is an unmistakable sexual tension between the self possessed Theo and Nell that Nell avoids. She puts on airs that she is attracted to Dr. Markway, but I think this too is one of her liesâ€¦a cover up. (To be honest, I consider every male character both living and dead in the movie to be a sort of â€œfalse lead.â€) She calls Theo â€œone of natureâ€™s mistakesâ€ and itâ€™s almost like someone else is speaking through her (her motherâ€™s words? Words once said to Nell?) It is clear that Nellâ€™s sister Dora has started a family, why not Nell? She may complain of having to take care of her ill mother but perhaps thatâ€™s been a convenient way to avoid something else.
When Markwayâ€™s wife appears and eliminates the doctorâ€™s usefulness as a decoy, Nell really begins to unravel. She realizes that there is no new world waiting to accept her and that she has no real identity to fall back on. The thoughts that we have been privy to from Nell sound a lot like those of a self-destructive drug addict (or cult member) trying to justify their actions. She wants to loose herself to something bigger to avoid looking at herself and tellingly, the first fright the house delivers her is a mirror (does she see a face or a wall?). Nell has been praying for freedom for eleven years but now that she has it can she handle it?
(Oh-oh, weâ€™re about to crash into a spoiler treeâ€¦jump out now!) In the book, Nell, rather than abandoning the false sense of security and purpose she’s found and returning to a world where she perceives herself as having nothing, completely obliterates herself by driving into a tree.
â€œI am really doing it, I am doing it all by myself, now, at last; this is me, I am really doing it by my-self.â€
Oh Nelly Nell, this is the same fucking mistake youâ€™ve made your whole life, confusing self actualization with fulfilling the needs of othersâ€¦in this case the needs of Hill House.
The movie lets her off the hook a smidge more than the book, as the steering wheel is clearly shown to be controlled by some unseen force that Nell resists. Still, there is the acknowledgment by Theo that Nell may have finally gotten exactly what she wanted. Unable to get a firm grip on either Theo’s or Markaway’s coat tails, Nell essentially resigns herself to the life (or death) of a shut-in, one of those who are housebound and “walk alone” (an eventual recluse herself JACKSON can be seen as the patron saint of the hermetic).
Nell’s experiences in Hill House though often frightening, also involved feelings of belonging that she had never experienced before. She had hope, there were possibilities around the corner and she felt important not just as a caretaker for someone elseâ€™s needs but because of her own individual gifts. Itâ€™s almost as if it were the positive feelings that she could not maintain that led her the most astray. It reminds me of the time I thought Iâ€™d help my friendâ€™s gold fish by giving them clean water to swim in and they all died of shock.
Itâ€™s easier to think that Nell was hoodwinked and therefore not responsible for her actions. In my recent viewing though I noticed an expression on her face during her kamikaze drive that I hadnâ€™t before. Itâ€™s an expression of ecstasy at having given in to the seductive, malevolent force, for having trashed the idea of “living” for good.
So hereâ€™s my new dilemma; I donâ€™t know whatâ€™s scarier, that face on the wall I started this post talking about or this newly discovered one. Was Nell happy to stay at Hill House? Did she end up gladly trading in an imagined inescapable situation for a very real one? Did she happily hop from one station of servitude to another, one mother to another? Look at the face below, doesnâ€™t that say it all?
This one and The Innocents together are A-#1.Â Top of the heap.Â Kings of the hill.
Yes, I do believe that Nell was very happy to be the latest resident at Hill House, without a doubt.
One of the greatest horror films ever made.
…and nary a mention of that gawd-awful remake in the whole article. Good job!
Another great post, Unk! You’ve been on fire lately! Excellent consideration of both Jackson’s book and the excellent adaptation by Wise. (Your point about the director “teaching you how to watch a horror movie” is excellent and true.) THE HAUNTING will always be the scariest G-rated movie ever, for my money.
This movie does more with a few sounds than pretty much allÂ CGI laden horror flicks. It should be required viewing for any filmmakers before they set out to make a horror film.Â Same goes for for any reviewer in the press who deems any of the latest Hollywood releases “scary as Hell”.
Wonderful, wonderful post, as usual! The Haunting is a movie that keeps on giving. Every time I watch it, I find something new to love or some new aspect of a character revealed. I never get tired of it.
I’m so in love with Theo it’s ridic.
Such a beautiful movie.Â I finally saw this a few Halloween’s ago after being neglectful and it’s been on the re-watch list every season since then. As you mention, and FG in her comment, this is the movie that continues to give to you. New things are always found in the best of cinema. I also remember being struck with how beautiful this B&W picture looked on my big HDTV.
In the novel, Theo toyed with the idea of having an affair with Nell, but in the end rejected it.
In the movie, Theo was serious about Nell.
In the remake, Catherine Zeta-Jones claimed to be bisexual, but nobody really cared.
Me and AJ broke down and splurged on a decent flat screen TV this past Xmas and let me tell ya, watching this movie on it was a real pleasure. Every second of it offers something, it’s just incredible.
I know “The Wicker man” has been called “The Citizen Kane of horror movies” but nope, I think that The Haunting deserves that praise more.
FinalG, I feel the same about Theo, if Nell just followed her lead a bit more she might have made it. Incidentally, a scene was shot but later edited out that showed Theo at home breaking up with her girlfriend. She screams out the window of her apartment “I hate you!” to the woman and then goes to look in a mirror and says “I hate you too.” I’m kind of glad they cut it out because I don’t think seeing her say that to herself fits my idea of her character being self accepting but I would love to see the cut scene some day and check out more of Bloom’s performance.
Jaako, Me and AJ are fascinated by just how appalling that remake is. It’s such an over the top insult that it’s verging on parody. We will definitely be cooking up something involving that travesty soon. Thanks to all for all the great comments.
I think that scene would’ve made more sense in the novel, in the movie Theo had nothing to be ashamed about.
And I must confess that I kinda liked the remake when I first saw it, but back then I knew nothing about the original novel/movie.Â What can I say, I’m a sucker for flamboyant haunted houses, not even Owen Wilson could ruin the experience for me. Watching it again was a big mistake, though.
I have to admit whenever I stumble across the remake on TV…I HAVE to watch it. I can’t control myself! There’s almost a “Showgirls” level of camp to it. That ending with Nell saving the children’s souls is just excruciating for me but I watch it anyway to torture myself.Â I remember first seeing the teaser trailer for that remake and being so excited (goosebumps even!) and I usually love Lili Taylor (especially love her in “the addiction”) but it’s all so crass and gaudy and the CGI is so horrid. I think I had to avoid talking about the remake in this post cuz I knew if I started I’d never stop!
If the original is the Citizen Kane of horror, the remake is the “Batman and Robin” of horror.
I don’t blame you for liking it the first time you saw it though because haunted house movies are pretty much always fun.
Anyway…it’s going on the netflix que asap…like Nell, I’m a masochist!
My favorite horror film. Flawless. Thank you for writing such a sweet valentine for it!
Chris hit the nail on the head when he mentioned the use of sound in this film.Â Â The scene where the two female leads are in the bedroom is a masterpiece of sound production.
The remake was just a flaw filled mess.Â But what really killed it for me was how well lit the sets were.
I watched a movie that sounds a lot like this one when I was very young. One particular scene has had a life long affect on me. It was when Grace’s face showed through the trap door. The only difference is I remember her making a hissing or Haaaaa noise. Does she do this in the movie?
This was filmed in England at what is now The Ettington Park Hotel. You can stay there!
The intro and the coda to the book are the same. Ending with the line “Whatever walked Hill House, walked alone”. The irony is that at the end of the novel Eleanor thinks she is joining the house, finally belonging to something. And then the coda with the last line. Awesome novel and a pretty damned good movie.